Revelle Blog

Would You Like To Try A Size Up?

September 1, 2019

JoAnna Hartzmark
JoAnna Hartzmark

Yesterday, I had a disheartening experience when I received my latest Rent the Runway shipment (side note: I use RTR’s Unlimited subscription to rent clothes monthly — not an ad, just my actual life): I received a garment in my shipment that’s a size bigger than what I would consider the largest in my ‘usual’ size range, and it fit PERFECTLY.

I felt myself start to mentally spiral out of control (“But that’s not my size. This dress obviously runs WAY small. But I only ordered this size out of desperation…”). It was clearly a mistake, I was obviously bloated, and I tried to put it out my mind. But if I’m being honest with myself and with you all, which I’ve promised to do, I let that one moment ruin my entire day

“I let that one moment ruin my entire day.”

For those of you that haven’t gotten on the clothing rental bandwagon, first let me explain. I pay a monthly fee and get four garments of my own choosing sent to my apartment. If I don’t like one of them once I see it in person, it doesn’t fit, or once I’m done wearing it, I send it back and get a new one to take its place. This means that I have a constantly updating set of four garments that aren’t actually from my own wardrobe every month. The primary reason I love this service is that I’m at that age where literally everyone I know is getting married, so I have a constant stream of celebratory events that I need to get dressed up for in my social calendar. I promise I’m not exaggerating, in the last 18 months I’ve had TWENTY-THREE weddings. So instead of spending absurd amounts of money on a new dress for every single engagement party, shower, bachelorette party, not to mention the big day itself, I rent dresses. It’s saved me a lot of money, and I’d like to think it’s helped push me out of my comfort zone and try clothes I wouldn’t normally.

Foto – Pexels
Foto – Pexels

But the dark side of clothing rental is that, just like every e-commerce experience in the known universe, you have no idea how garments are going to fit you when you order them online. Sure, there are brands you wear a lot so you’re reasonably sure what size you wear, but in general it’s a bit of a crapshoot with RTR because there are so many brands to choose from, and as I mentioned I try not to limit myself to those I know well. So that means I’m frequently torn between taking up more than one of my four garment ‘slots’ with the same dress in different sizes vs ordering four different garments and hoping they all fit. And that brings us to yesterday’s fiasco.

I was already cutting it close not having a dress for this weekend’s wedding, and I have three garments at home that I really like and am not done wearing (sometimes I rent things not for weddings to pretend that I have other things going on in my life too). So that means that I had only one spot open to try to get a dress for this weekend — I know, I’m playing a risky game. Now I’ll note that RTR did recently launch an option to add an extra fifth slot for a fee, but on principle I’m trying to avoid using it because I already give them so much of my money, so suffice it to say I was determined to use this one slot to find my dress for the weekend.

I browsed through their dresses and eventually found one I liked, but of course it wasn’t currently available in my size. I looked at the extremely helpful customer reviews and photos, and deduced that the dress was actually pretty tight but still stretchy, so ordering a bigger size might not look all that bad, even if it technically didn’t fit the way it looked on the model (as if it ever does…). So I ordered the bigger size — and not just the bigger of my ‘usual’ range of sizes, but even one above that.

Well, imagine my dismay when I tried on the dress and it fit perfectly. Like a glove. Like it was made for me. Now, part of this was that the curve-hugging style happened to simply flatter my ‘hourglass’ shape (I’m honestly reluctant to even type that, because what do those shapes even mean anyway??). But the other part was that I had gotten a size that I would normally refuse to order purely on principle. And it turned out that that’s the size that I should actually be wearing in this particular dress.

Can you imagine what happened next? I’ll bet you can. Rather of reveling in my beautiful reflection in the mirror and thinking about how f*cking fabulous I’m going to look at this wedding (less fabulous than the bride of course, don’t worry, I’m not a monster) — instead I felt this soul-crushing SHAME that I had to wear a size bigger than the range that I had totally arbitrarily decided ‘defined’ me. How ridiculous is that??

Why is it that a single moment like this has the power to crush our self-esteem for the rest of the day (or week, or month, or year)? Without even realizing it, I spent the rest of the day yesterday more conscious about what I was eating, feeling guilty about the fact that I’d already decided my body needed a rest day from working out, and doing a mental tally of how many outfits I’d rented recently that I had had to size up in. The power that this single, totally insignificant moment had over me was totally overwhelming, and I had no power to even identify it was happening let alone stop it.

This all stems from the totally unrealistic expectations that society, brands, and other companies put on us as women. We’re told over and over again that our size defines us, our diet defines us, and beyond that we’re even told which sizes and diets are ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ at any given time. It’s only recently that it’s become mainstream to even talk about how having a non-model body might actually be acceptable, or even healthy. And even then, it’s still sort of on the fringes, everyone still sort of wants to have that model body — but now we also have to pretend that having that body is achievable with balance and isn’t actually a result of strict, unhealthy diets and body-crushing exercise routines.

What I realized yesterday is that even as someone who thinks about these issues all the time, seeks out role models and confidants who are supportive of REAL women, I still have to fight the battle every single day to love myself as I am. I let my entire emotional wellbeing sit on a single size in a tiny tag that no one would ever even see. Why does that number even matter??

show comments on this post (1)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

  1. Avatar

    This is spot-on… it’s crazy how something so subjective and trivial can completely alter how we feel about ourselves moment to moment!

You may also like

10 Best Jeans For Pear-Shaped Women (and why we hate that phrase)

7 Things The Revelle HQ Is Buzzing About This Month [October]

12 Ways To Style Ripped Jeans

5 Ways To Style Light-Wash Denim

How to Distress Your Jeans: A Step-By-Step Guide

10 Of Our Favorite White Wide Leg Jeans

5 Ways To Stretch Out Your Jeans

7 Things The Revelle HQ Is Buzzing About This Month [September]

10 High-Waisted Wide Leg Jeans We L-O-V-E

8 Tips For Styling Mom Jeans

10 Black Jeans We’re Loving Right Now

6 Best Jeans For Women With Big Butts

Q&A With Revelle’s Social Lead (& Thrift Shopping Guru), Katie Paganelli

On Career Shifts & Building Confidence With Storytelling Coach Carolyn Stine

17 Flattering Blue Jeans For Women In Various Styles & Washes

8 Best Bootcut Jeans For Women

7 Things The Revelle HQ Is Buzzing About This Month [August]

12 Of Our Top Plus-Size Jeans For Women

Q&A With Revelle’s Product Lead (& Classically Trained Actor), Brianne Wilson

12 Best Maternity Jeans On The Market Right Now

How To Wear Ankle Boots With Jeans (+10 of our favorite pairs)

This Is What The Small Pocket On Jeans Is *Actually* For

17 Most Comfortable Jeans In Our Closet

8 Ways To Tell If Your Jeans Fit Properly When You Try Them On

Around The World In Jeans: The Best International Denim Brands (& Styles) By Country

7 Things The Revelle HQ Is Buzzing About This Month [July]

10 Classic Straight Leg Jeans For Women

Representation Should Never Be “Revolutionary”

8 High-Waisted Ripped Jeans We Love

16 Best Jeans Under $100

12 Movies Starring Strong Female Leads

7 Cream-Colored Jeans We’re *Swooning* Over

21 Tweets That Perfectly Encapsulate Our *Complicated* Relationship With Jeans

12 Cropped Jeans We’re LOVING This Summer

7 Things The Revelle HQ Is Buzzing About This Month [June]

The Best Women’s Jeans On Sale Right Now [Updated 6/10]

8 Animal Print Jeans That’ll Spice Up Your Wardrobe Big Time

Discover The Fascinating History Of Women’s Jeans In The U.S.

22 Best Skinny Jeans For Women

Q&A With Social Intern (& Model, & Owner Of A Clothing Line) Madison Whittaker

15 Best Mom Jeans (2021)

8 Best Butt-Shaping Jeans

3 Revelle Updates To Get Excited About

7 Of The Best Travel Jeans For Women

7 Things The Revelle HQ Is Buzzing About This Month [May]

How To Fold Jeans: A Step-By-Step Guide

Q&A With Imani Ribadeneyra, The Marathon-Running, Social Media Maven Behind Revelle

Please Don’t Conflate A Pandemic With A “Creative Retreat”

How To Wear Jeans To Work & Still Look Professional

10 Tips For Buying Jeans Online That Fit (The First Time)

Model-Turned-Poet Ngozi Kemjika Opens Up About Her Self-Love Journey

8 Feminist Podcasts On Gender, Inclusivity, & Body Positivity

10 Best Jeans For Women With Strong, Athletic Thighs & Calves

7 Things The Revelle HQ Is Buzzing About This Month [April]

How To Pull Off The Classic Jean-on-Jean Look

10 Best Tummy-Control Jeans

Cutting Through The Oversimplified Archetype Of “The Parisian Woman”

Q&A With JoAnna Hartzmark, Founder & CEO Of Revelle

How To Properly Wash And Dry Your Jeans

12 Books With Strong Female Characters

12 Best Jeans For Petite Women

7 Things The Revelle HQ Is Buzzing About This Month [March]

Yes, You Can Wear White Jeans In Winter. Here’s How.

Q&A With Samantha Guidoin, Revelle’s Paris-Born, Florida-Bred Graphic Designer

7 Types Of Jeans For Women: A Complete Guide

Navigating Pandemic Pressures Around Weight & Body Image

TikTok Doesn’t Have to be Toxic

The Fitting Room: My Least Favorite Place on Earth

6 Best Jeans For Tall Women

Best Brands for…Small Waists and Big Hips

You Can’t Sit With Us

What’s Your Size?

Does Size Matter?

The Origin Of The Size Chart

Living Life To The Fullest

How To Waste A Life

Clothes Case: Bodysuits

What Our Closets Say About Us (Behind Our Backs, Of Course)

Would You Like To Try A Size Up?

Where Do Brands Get Their Size Charts In The First Place?

Greetings from Revelle

show comments on this post (0)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.